Payroll in Excel vs. payroll software: what’s the difference? Which one fits your company?
If your company has only a few employees, fixed salaries, and no complicated shifts or overtime, running payroll in Excel can still work, and there is no software cost.
This page compares the two approaches using the real tasks you handle every month, with cost examples at 10, 50, and 100 employees, so you can see where your own company’s break-even point sits.
Monthly tasks compared
| Task | With Excel | With a system |
|---|---|---|
| 01Collecting clock-in and clock-out times | Key in data from the scanner or timesheets into the file yourself | Data flows into the system as soon as employees clock in |
| 02Calculating OT and shifts | Write the formulas and check them yourself every time the rules change | Set the rules once, and the system calculates by the rules you set |
| 03Leave and approval documents | Chase leave forms and summarize them in a separate file | Submit and approve in the system, flowing straight into the calculation |
| 04Tax and Social Security | Update rates and ceilings yourself every time the law changes | The system updates with the law for you |
| 05Issuing payslips | Prepare and send them yourself | Employees view them on their own in the system |
| 06Risk of miscalculation | A wrong formula or a mis-dragged cell often goes unnoticed until an employee points it out | Calculated from the same rules every period, with a full audit trail |
| 07Auditing past periods | Have to find the right version of the file | Edit history is kept in the system |
| 08Access to payroll data | Anyone with the file sees the entire file | Control who can see what, down to the level you choose |
| 09When the payroll person leaves | Knowledge and files stay with the individual | Rules and data stay in the system, so work can be handed over |
| 10Time per cycle | Depends on headcount and rule complexity | Decreases once the rules are fully set up |
See the difference? Try the real system before you decide to give up Excel30-day free trial with every HR function · No credit card needed
30-day free trialExcel is still enough when… Switch to a system when…
Excel is still enough when
- You have fewer than 5-10 employees
- No complicated shifts or OT
- No multiple branches
- You rarely need to audit past periods
- You already have an experienced payroll person
Switch to a system when
- Headcount keeps growing
- You have complex shifts or multiple OT rates
- You are starting to have multiple branches
- You need to audit past periods more often
- Only one person handles payroll (a risk if they leave)
Cost at 10 / 50 / 100 employees
Compare “the time your payroll person spends each month × their hourly rate” against the cost of a system. At 10 employees or fewer, it starts at 590 THB/month (BASIC), with a 30-day free trial before you decide. The hourly rate below is a figure you enter yourself, not a fixed reference value.
Range 1–10 employees · Price per month, excluding 7% VAT
✓ From 590 THB/month (BASIC, up to 10 employees) · 30-day free trial · 2 months free on the ADVANCED plan, then 50% off from month 3, for organizations with up to 10 employees, until 31 Dec 2026
Over 500 employees: custom enterprise pricing. Ask us at 1537
30-day free trial From 590 THB/month (BASIC, up to 10 employees) · No credit card needed
Is it illegal to run payroll in Excel?
No. What the law requires is accurate wage payment, tax and social security withholding and remittance, and keeping the related documents, whether you calculate in Excel or in a system. The company is always responsible for accuracy.
Is it hard to move data from Excel into a system?
Send your payroll Excel file or employee data to our team and we will handle it for you, free on every plan.
- Step 1
Gather the details of your payroll calculation rules and company data
- Step 2
Configure the system to your actual rules
- Step 3
Train your HR and admins to use it
- Step 4
Test and go live
Generally you can start within your company’s next payroll cycle, and if your data is already ready, as fast as 1-5 business days. Historical data of up to 1 year can be imported.
Ready to give up Excel? Send us your file and we will set up the system for freeFree on every plan · Start in as fast as 1-5 business days if your data is ready
Sign up for the free trialSummary
Payroll in Excel vs. payroll software What’s the difference, and which fits your company?
1How Excel and a system differ
- Collecting clock-in and clock-out timesExcel: key in yourself · System: data flows in instantly
- Calculating OT and shiftsExcel: write formulas yourself · System: set rules once
- Tax and Social SecurityExcel: update yourself · System: updated with the law for you
- Access to payroll dataExcel: anyone with the file sees it · System: you control access
2Excel is still enough when
- You have fewer than 5-10 employees
- No complicated shifts or OT
- No multiple branches
- You rarely need to audit past periods
- You already have an experienced payroll person
3Switch to a system when
- Headcount keeps growing
- You have complex shifts or multiple OT rates
- You are starting to have multiple branches
- You need to audit past periods more often
- Only one person handles payroll (a risk if they leave)
4Moving data from Excel into the system (free on every plan)
- Step 1Gather the details of your payroll calculation rules and company data
- Step 2Configure the system to your actual rules
- Step 3Train your HR and admins to use it
- Step 4Test and go live
5HumanSoft in summary
- Starting at590 THB/monthfor 10 employees
- Free trial30 daysNo credit card needed
- Fastest start1-5 business daysif your data is ready
- Historical data importUp to 1 year
Law · Running payroll in Excel is not illegal, but accurate wage payment, tax and Social Security withholding and remittance, and document retention are always the company’s responsibility
Frequently asked questions
Still have questions? Ask the AI assistant right away, or browse all FAQs.
Can I run payroll in Excel?
Yes, if you have fewer than about 5 employees and no complicated OT. But you must update the tax formulas yourself every year, and there is no audit trail of edits. As headcount grows, the risk of miscalculation grows with it.
Is it illegal to run payroll in Excel?
No. What the law requires is accurate payment, withholding and remittance, and document retention. Using Excel itself is not an offense, as long as the figures and documents are accurate and complete.
Is it hard to move data from Excel into a system?
Send your payroll Excel file or employee data to our team and we will handle it for you, free on every plan. Our team takes care of everything from importing the data, configuring the system to your actual rules, and training your HR and admins, through to testing before go-live. Generally you can start within your company’s next payroll cycle, and if your data is already ready, as fast as 1-5 business days.
How far back can data be imported?
Historical data of up to 1 year can be imported.
Can I try the system before deciding to give up Excel?
Try it free for 30 days with every function, and no credit card needed for HR work. Evaluate the value before you decide to pay.
What does it cost to get started?
From 590 THB/month (BASIC, up to 10 employees, excl. 7% VAT) · 30-day free trial with every feature, no credit card (**Free for 2 months on the ADVANCED plan; from month 3, get 50% off for organizations of up to 10 employees, until Dec 31, 2026)